The Role of Discovery in Florida Family Law Cases

Ever wonder how the cards are dealt in family law proceedings like divorce? It’s not all about dramatic courtroom showdowns or tearful negotiations. Much of the groundwork happens behind the scenes during the “discovery phase,” where the magic (or mayhem) of gathering information occurs. This phase is where both parties lay their financial cards on the table, ensuring fair play and transparency.

What Are Mandatory Disclosures?

In the Sunshine State, when you file for divorce, you’re not just signing papers; you’re signing up to disclose your financial life. Within 45 days of the petition being served, both parties are expected to automatically exchange key financial documents. These disclosures allow for all of your cards to be put on the table.

Financial affidavits are a critical part of this packet. These documents lay out each party’s financial facts, from income and expenses to assets and debts. Only in rare cases—like a non-contested dissolution of marriage without children and with both parties in full agreement—can these affidavits be waived. And even then, they must attest that they’ve exchanged these affidavits privately and are making decisions based on the disclosed information. Beware. If you skip this step and later dispute the agreement based on undisclosed finances, you might find yourself in hot water for perjury.

Additional Discovery Tools

Beyond the basics, parties can dig deeper with additional discovery tools, essential for uncovering more than just financial facts. These include:

Requests for Production of Documents: Need specific documents? This tool compels the other party to hand over pertinent documents, assuming they can access them. Whether it’s employment contracts or projected income statements from Social Security, if it’s under their control, they must provide it.

Interrogatories: These are the probing questions one party poses to the other, which must be answered under oath. If interrogatories are used, there are seven required questions and then a party can serve an additional ten questions.

Subpoenas and Depositions: Sometimes, you need information from someone outside the marriage—like employers or banks. Subpoenas help fetch this data. Depositions, on the other hand, involve questioning a party or a witness under oath before a court reporter, much like in a courtroom setting.

The Impact of Discovery

Why endure this often tedious phase? Because discovery levels the playing field. Both parties gain access to the same comprehensive information, enabling fair negotiations and informed decisions. This transparency reduces misunderstandings and minimizes conflicts, paving the way for smoother resolutions.

The breadth of information requested might sometimes feel invasive, but under the rules of procedure, a party may request any relevant information. It is important to note that even if the requested information may not be admissible at trial under the rules of evidence, the discovery is permissible if it appears to reasonably lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. And unless a discovery request is deemed to intentionally stall the process or is unnecessarily burdensome, it generally stands.

Timelines and Legal Nuances

Discovery isn’t a sprint; it’s more of a marathon. Patience is key, as gathering all necessary information can take time. Lawyers often grant extensions to ensure all pertinent data is collected responsibly and thoroughly. This is not about dragging things out but ensuring that every relevant piece of information is considered to evaluate the case and determine the next step.

Good faith efforts in obtaining and sharing information are not just encouraged but required. Before rushing to the court to compel discovery, lawyers must engage with their counterparts to discuss and resolve any disputes regarding the requests. This collaborative approach, though sometimes frustratingly slow, is designed to foster fairness and resolution outside of court, if possible.

If you’re going through a family law matter, understanding and effectively managing the discovery process is important for every case, no matter how straightforward they seem. At Heather Bryan Law, P.A., our goal is to make sure every piece of necessary information is carefully considered to protect your interests and rights. For more guidance or to discuss your case, call us at (863) 825-5309. We’re here to help you through every step of your legal process with clarity and compassion.

The following two tabs change content below.

Heather Bryan Law, P.A.

Our firm has experience defending Floridians against all sorts of criminal charges. Additionally, we are well-equipped to handle emotionally charged family law matters and devastating personal injury cases.

Latest posts by Heather Bryan Law, P.A. (see all)